Unicorn Birthday Party

This past weekend was Clare’s 5th birthday party. Her love affair with pink continues but we have moved on from Princesses… to Unicorn Princesses. So if you have a unicorn princess under your roof, you might want to take some notes. This was an insanely fun party and for the first time, Clare helped me with a bunch of the planning. That was the best part! Happy birthday big girl! I can’t believe I’ve been a mama for 5 years!

How quirky and fun are these Unicorn Rubber Duckies?
On Friday morning (48 hours before kick-off) I spotted these ice-pops on Elizabeth Street’s Pinterest, immediately searched for them online and had them shipped overnight. I don’t mess around when it comes to unicorn pops. I asked you on Facebook for tips on quick freezing pops and our friend Macki sent me her Rainbow Fruit Pop recipe. I took the quick-freeze one step further and pre-froze my chopped fruit. 6 batches of pops in 18 hours! Nice! These are so delicious and refreshing. If your crew likes a little more sweet with their tart, give the frozen pops a roll in sugar.Unicorn horns of course. Here’s how to make DIY Unicorn Horn Party Hats  Moms are telling me that everyone is still wearing them non-stop at home. Win.The pretty little stars filled with jewels were part of a scavenger hunt. A series of clues led the band of unicorns around the house. At every location there was cup of jewels for each girl to add a treasure to her bag. It got pretty intense. There were also tails, of course. Simple bunches of ribbon and star wire tied to elastic waistbands. This was another fun project for Clare and I to do together.To make 24 ice pops with one mold, I had to use wooden sticks. To control drips, I made a small slit in the bottom of paper cupcake cups and slid them up the stick. Clare painted this beautiful unicorn poster to play “pin the horn on the unicorn.” Unfortunately, if you use foam stickers for your horns, little girls who are geniuses will feel for the pieces already on the paper. Now I just feel silly.
Clare loved her unicorn cake. I used our Evil Buttercream Icing recipe and How to Ice a Cake tutorial. The “5” the “river” and the flower are cut from Wilton Sugar Sheets. They. Are. Awesome. I plan to use them in many quick cake decorating projects.Thank you my precious unicorn princess. Planning a unicorn party has been a lifelong dream come true. 8-year-old Jacinda is impressed and yet totally jealous.




The difference to me is that with fondant, it is dependent on the taste because typically you are replacing some/all of the buttercream. The sugar sheets are literally paper thin and you just lay it on top of the buttercream. It sort-of melts into the frosting and you don’t notice a taste/texture. I can’t wait to use the precut letters. So easy! I dont have any of the punches, I just cut it with scissors which was very easy. It would also be fun to write on them with food writers. I resisted for a year and will now definitely use them again.


Oh.my.word! I’ve only just finished my 4yr olds rainbow party end of march and she too is now obsessed with unicorns! Fairy unicorns with wings to be precise actually! I’m not sure how my darling husband will be able to cope if I start planning this early out!
I will have to let her pick the theme…a little bit closer to the time, but thank you SO much for the great ideas! I wouldn’t have known where to start – ill be saving this page for sure!!
(I suppose the 1st & 3rd birthday parties should be planned first however!)


DIY please! The horns are too cute…but I wouldn’t know where to start!


A DIY on the horns would be great or a quick list of supplies for what the horn is made out of. Thanks and great job on the unicorn party. I am currently scoping out ideas for a Lago party 2 months away, but I do have a little girl that will be 5 in Jan…

Bex Angell

I have seen several unicorn headbands, but would like a list of supplies that you used since your blog entry stated the girls were wearing them after the party. Any durability is appreciated. Thanks.


I also would like some hints on the unicorn headbands! I have figured out the actual horn, but am having trouble because they seem to be too top heavy? Maybe I need a wider headband? Help!

Sarah I

This is so perfect timing. My Daughter is turning 5 and we’ll be having a party at the end of the month and she just informed me that she wants it to be all about unicorns. Yay, Thanks for the great ideas.

Mindee Hass

Glad the Popsicle sticks & cupcake wrappers worked so well. We love these Popsicle makers!


Such a great party! Do you have a tutorial for the cookies? I tried finding it on your web site, but I wasn’t successful. I love them!

Elizabeth M

I am using many of these ideas for my soon-to-be 4 y/o….so many great ideas!!! Can you please send me a tutorial for the unicorn horns? Thanks for the inspiration:)


Great ideas on here! Thanks for posting! I love the sugar sheets ideas and thanks to you, will incorporate them into my soon-to-be 5 year old daughter’s magic forest/unicorn party cake! I am also making unicorn horns… and can let your readers know that you can buy pre-made party hats at Oriental Trading Company and roll them tight (they come in all colors, plain with no writing or design, and flat, with string). Once you’ve rolled them to the size you want, glue or tape them, then you can decorate them as you wish. I bought sequin trim and other sparkly ribbon at Michaels. Can not wait for this party! We’ve already done a Princess party, Fairy party, Mermaid/Under the Sea (to incorporate boy sharks) party, circus party, ninja party, and now the Magical Forest/Unicorn party (again to incorporate boys with girls.. boys can be dragons, gnomes, elves, or woodland creatures).


I’d love a list of supplies for the unicorn horns. I might be able to figure it out if I knew what the horn was actually made out of? Anyone know? I’m clueless.


Could you send me the DIY of the horns? Or the supply list? LOVE the horns, they are so cute and should be a great activity for kids.


Glad I am not the only one who yes would need instructions on the horns.Could you please share.They would go great with my daughters rainbow party we are planning for her next birthday.

Jasmine Williamson

It looks like the horns are made out of craft foam, probably the already sparkly kind. And then some sequin ribbon glued on. Glue the thing onto some dollar store plastic headbands and voila. Did I get it right?


I would love the DIY instructions on the unicorn horn headbands! Thinking of a Goldilicious themed party for my little girl!!!


My 3 year old is already planning her next birthday (it’s not until November…). But this persistent child is already talking purple, sparkly unicorns! Your post has definitely provided some inspiration!!


I made 3 dozen unicorn headbands for my daughter’s 5th birthday this past weekend. They were a TOTAL hit!! The kids took extra horns home to siblings. I bought plain plastic headbands from Oriental Trading. Then I bought a pack of glitter foam paper from Hobby Lobby and some plain foam paper without glitter for the circle under the headband. I twisted the glitter foam paper into a funnel and glued it together. I had to wrap rubber bands around it over night for the glue to dry. Then I cut the bottom so it would sit flat on the table. Then I cut half inch slits all around the base of the horn to create tabs. Next I cut a circle from the non-glitter paper the size of the base of the horn. I put the circle base under the headband and the horn on top of the headband then used the tabs to glue the horn and base together with the headband in the middle. I used barrettes to hold everything together until it was dry. They were very stable and the kids loved them. Thank you so much for the idea!!!


Hi there, firstly well done…what a wonderful party you organised for your gorgeous little girl…I am planning a magical rainbow unicorn party for my twin girls who are turning two in October and I simply LOVE your unicorn headbands…would you mind sharing how you made them???? I look forward to hearing from you ….

Thanks G


An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a colleague who has been conducting a little homework on this.
And he in fact bought me dinner simply because I stumbled upon
it for him… lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the
meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending some time to discuss this matter here on your site.

dagonvale breeding tips

Excellent goods from you, man. I’ve consider your stuff previous to and you are just extremely great.
I actually like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you’re
stating and the way in which wherein you say it. You are making it entertaining and you continue
to care for to stay it sensible. I cant wait to learn much more from
you. That is really a great website.

eve cheats

Hi there! This is my first visit to your blog!

We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in
a community in the same niche. Your blog provided us valuable information to
work on. You have done a extraordinary job!

Sarah WHiteside

Please send me the DIY tutorial for the Unicorn Party Hats. I have never performed a DIY project like this before and need basic instructions that a first-time do-it-yourselfer can follow! The hats are perfect for my daughters upcoming 4th birthday party!


I’d love the tutorial on the unicorn hats, please. Preparing for my daughter’s 5th birthday. Thanks!


May I also please get the DIY instructions for the unicorn headbands…they are awesome!
Thank you so much.


I would love your DIY instructions for the unicorn headbands if you’re willing to pass them along. A unicorn party is being requested by my very soon to be 6 yr old and those are so cute!


Better late (um, by three years) than never! I posted a tutorial for the horns today.

Unicorn Party

[…] lollipops and, of course, glittery unicorn horns.  Thankfully, we had the lovely Jacinda at Pretty Prudent to inspire us with super cute ideas, including a DIY unicorn horn.  A little glitter paper, glue […]


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *